This previously undisclosed document is a five-page summary of an unsigned, unofficial “white paper” developed by the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel. It was written in January 2010 by David Barron, then the acting head of the office and now a federal appeals court judge. I discuss it in Chapter 7, Section 2: “Democrats Get to […]
Author: Charlie Savage
Power Wars Document: Lindsey Graham’s grand bargain proposal over Guantanamo
This previously undisclosed document is a proposal Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina, developed in 2009. It was a starting point for what became lengthy but unsuccessful negotiations with the Obama White House over a grand bargain on detainee policies. (The existence of those negotiations has been reported.) I discuss it in Chapter 4, Section […]
The first review of Power Wars, and my response
The New York Times has published the first review of Power Wars. They commissioned James Mann, a non-NYT staffer and the author of Rise of the Vulcans and The Obamians, to write it to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest. Mann’s review is generally very positive, and he engages thoughtfully with some of […]
Derived from Power Wars: How 4 Federal Lawyers Paved the Way to Kill Bin Laden
Read it here in the New York Times.
Obama’s evolution on security vs. individual rights in two quotes
We are six days out from the publication of “Power Wars,” an investigative history of the Obama administration’s national-security legal policymaking. It goes behind the scenes to explore the space between these two Obama quotes in its epigraph:
Upstream Internet Surveillance Confusion
A Federal District Court judge today threw out the ACLU-led challenge to the NSA’s warrantless upstream surveillance of one-end-foreign Internet communications under the FISA Amendments Act, ruling that the plaintiffs, including Wikimedia Foundation, had not established standing. The case touched on an article that I wrote in August 2013, early in the post-Snowden leak era, […]
Power Wars teaser GIF: “Never Been Reported”
Obama vetoes National Defense Authorization Act in part over Gitmo closure
Here is the relevant part of his veto message to Congress.
A secret (for now) appeals court ruling in our targeted killing FOIA lawsuit
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has issued what appears to be a significant ruling in the ongoing NYT/ACLU Freedom of Information Act lawsuit for legal memos related to targeted killings — but we can’t see it yet. The court has made certain redactions in its opinion, and the government now has 30 days […]
Power Wars Shoutouts
It’s a team effort to bring national security issues to light. Here are some non-NYT colleagues I thank in Power Wars: